Pay-for-performance models have the potential to improve employee performance and productivity. Compensating employees based on the value they bring to the organization creates a unique incentive for them to further develop their professional skills. 

For your pay-for-performance model to be effective, it needs to be optimized for your organization’s operations, goals, and culture. A well-developed pay-for-performance model produces a symbiotic relationship where your business thrives, and your employees feel valued for their contributions. 

Here’s how to design an effective pay-for-performance model and implement it at your organization.  

{{multiplier-cta}}

Understand the Implications of This Compensation Model

Performance-based compensation will change both your budget and your company culture. You should understand the unique benefits and drawbacks that this model offers before choosing to implement one.

With this approach, employees usually receive lower base salaries than they would in a traditional compensation scheme but then receive additional compensation based on their work performance. 

These lower base salaries mean that a pay-for-performance model is less expensive up front, but you’ll end up spending more money on your highest performers. However, strong employee performance often correlates with the financial success of your organization as a whole, which can offset these compensation increases. 

Pay-for-performance can also affect your company culture. Many organizations find that this approach improves productivity and engagement. However, it can also lead to increased competition and stress levels. Everyone responds differently to this model — some employees will thrive, while others might feel overwhelmed or intimidated. You’ll need to prepare for these potential shifts and put safeguards in place to prevent them. 

Understanding these implications is necessary to determine whether pay-for-performance is right for your organization. Assess how these changes will implement your operations in the long term and what the benefits will look like. 

Choose the Right Pay-For-Performance Model

There are many ways to implement a pay-for-performance model. Some of the most popular pay-for-performance structures include: 

• Performance-based salaries: Employees have the potential to receive salary raises at periodic intervals if they hit specific performance benchmarks. 
• Bonuses: Employees receive additional compensation beyond their base salary for good performance. In a pay-for-performance model, bonuses are usually tied to employee performance metrics. However, they can also be given on a discretionary basis. 
• Sales commissions: Employees receive a pre-defined percentage of the sales they make or are involved with. Commission models are often tiered, so salespeople receive a higher commission rate as their sales grow. 
• Profit sharing and stock options: Employees receive a percentage of the company’s profit each year. Publicly traded companies typically offer stock options instead of profit sharing. 

You might also choose to implement a combination of these models to best reflect the work your team is doing. In some cases, different roles will require different compensation models. For example, you might use a commission-based model for your sales team and a bonus model for your non-sales teams. 

The right compensation model for your organization will depend on factors like your size, financial status, and industry. Some industries are more likely to use pay-for-performance models than others in general. For example, the financial sector has the highest rate of pay-for-performance use at 67%, while the leisure and hospitality sector has the lowest at just 18%. 

Award Behavior You Want Repeated

Once you’ve decided which pay-for-performance model makes sense for your organization, the next step is to determine which behaviors to reward in the workplace. One of the most effective ways to do this is by looking at the existing work processes of your top-performing team members. What strategies do they use that would be highly impactful on a large scale?

For example, maybe your most successful salespeople consistently check in with existing customers, which helps boost sales and results in more customer loyalty. To encourage this behavior across your entire sales team, you could increase commissions or bonus amounts for salespeople that keep repeat customers coming back. 

This approach can apply to roles across your entire organization. You can even reward behavior that isn’t directly tied to increasing revenue, such as meeting hiring goals for HR staff. The key to setting performance benchmarks is picking goals that are quantifiable and trackable. 

Set Individual and Team Performance Benchmarks

One of the biggest challenges of any pay-for-performance model is that it can incentivize competition rather than teamwork. To combat this, set both individual pay benchmarks for employees as well as comprehensive benchmarks for the team to encourage collaboration.

Team benchmarks also solve another major challenge that comes with pay-for-performance models, which is keeping average performers motivated and incentivized.

Employees who don’t consistently meet high-level performance benchmarks can get frustrated when they don’t receive the additional compensation that their teammates get. Rewarding strong team performance can help keep everyone engaged and incentivized.

In fact, group performance pay has been found to increase productivity by as much as 18% in some cases. 

Implement Unbiased Performance Tracking

After setting your performance goals, you’ll need to find the right tech tools to track them. The right tools for you will depend on your industry and the specific compensation model you’re using. Regardless of which tools you use, it’s crucial that your employees have access to their own performance data in real time, as well as relevant team data. This ensures that everyone has the ability to track their progress and prevents any confusion or misunderstandings. 

When tracking employee performance, it’s essential to use hard, objective data and extensive documentation. More than 60% of employees believe that their workplace is biased, so it’s important to address these concerns head-on. 

It’s also important to implement manual anti-bias checks. For example, you can have performance data reviewed by leaders in different departments to identify any inconsistencies or points of concern. 

Safeguard Employees From Unexpected Events

Your pay-for-performance model should reward team members for their contributions to your business rather than punishing them for things that are outside of their control.

While data is very important, you also need some flexibility in your compensation strategy for when numbers don’t tell the whole story. 

This is particularly important for roles that are highly affected by external factors like economic fluctuation. Consider including opportunities for subjective, performance-based compensation at management’s discretion. This can help prevent sharp drops in compensation due to outlier events. It also provides the opportunity to compensate excellent work performance that doesn’t fit neatly into your KPIs. 

Schedule Regular Reviews and Make Adjustments

Your pay-for-performance program should be dynamic and reflect the natural evolution of your organization. It’s important to make adjustments as time goes on and your organizational goals change. 

Have a review schedule in place for each individual employee, for your teams, and for your organization as a whole. There should be enough time in place to schedule interventions and provide support if an employee isn’t on track to meet their goals. 

When assessing your overall performance model, consider how it has affected employee productivity and well-being. If employees are consistently struggling with burnout or failing to meet benchmarks, it’s likely a sign that compensation needs to be evaluated. You can also make adjustments to your compensation model as your organization grows. For example, if you go public, you might want to consider stock options as a reward in addition to bonuses or commissions. 

Focus on Transparency

When switching from a traditional compensation model to a pay-for-performance model, it’s understandable for your employees to have questions and maybe even feel concerned. Transparency in your communications will help your team feel more comfortable with this shift. 

Start by communicating with employees about why you’re making this shift and the benefits they can expect going forward. It’s also crucial to have your entire pay-for-performance model documented in writing and accessible to your entire team. When hiring new employees, provide clarity about your pay-for-performance model up front as well. 

Give employees ways to provide feedback about your compensation model. This could be formal feedback forms and surveys, informal meetings with management, or both. This will help management accurately assess the efficacy of your compensation model and make adjustments as necessary. 

Optimize Your Pay-For-Performance Model With CaptivateIQ

When building your pay-for-performance model, it’s important to consider your organizational needs and culture. Part of this is choosing the right technology. CaptivateIQ streamlines your commissions management with automatic calculations and transparency for your team members. Schedule a demo today to see how you can transform your pay-for-performance model.